Hamilton is credited with bringing musical theater back to the mainstream. Now, over a decade later, a stellar new cast carries its legacy.
Though the initial impression was disappointing, as many essential roles were filled in with understudies, any doubts were quelled the moment their characters made their debut. Miriam Ali brought youthful energy to Peggy before seducing the whole theater as Maria, while Amanda Simone Lee carried the warmth, strength, and emotion needed to bring Eliza to life.
However, the big stand-outs were Jimmie “J.J.” Jeter as Aaron Burr and A.D. Weaver as George Washington.
Jeter’s performance took some getting used to, with his unique choice to portray Burr’s public persona with more exaggerated sarcasm than before. However, his inner passion shone through in his performances of “Wait For It” and “Dear Theodosia,” as well as in his nailing the awe and disbelief at Hamilton’s resilience and accomplishments in “Non-Stop”.
Meanwhile, A.D. Weaver brought a larger-than-life presence to Washington’s military persona, with his deep, commanding voice. Don’t let that deep voice fool you, as Act 2 showcased his vocal range with “One Last Time” and his underrated chops as an M.C. for the Cabinet Battles.
The additional cast was fantastic as well, with Marja Harmon bringing Angelica’s powerful older sister energy to life. Christian Magby as Marquis de Lafayette/Thomas Jefferson and Eddie Ortega as Hercules Mulligan/James Madison brought fresh talent and respect to Hamilton’s old war buddies and his political rivals. While Nathan Haydel was exceptional as John Laurens, his youthful portrayal of Phillip Hamilton brought a much-needed energy to an otherwise tragic chapter of Hamilton’s story.
Matt Bittner as King George had the audience erupting with laughter, and even had Jeter breaking character at one point.
Of course, Tyler Fauntleroy, as Hamilton himself, carried eagerness, determination, non-stop energy, and the reckless confidence needed to bring the title character to life.
With audience members younger than the show itself cosplaying in its iconic, colorful colonial wardrobe, it’s clear that this show’s legacy will continue to thrive for decades to come.
Hamilton runs through June 14 at the Durham Performing Arts Center. For more information, visit https://www.dpacnc.com/.